Bradford Central School is a member of Section V in the New York State Public High School Athletic Association and is a member of the Steuben County Athletic Association. Based on enrollment, BCS is classified as a class D school along with the other smallest schools in Section V.
In 2008-2009, BCS will field interscholastic teams in soccer (boys' varsity, girls' varsity, modified), basketball (boys' modified, girls' modified, boys' JV, girls' JV, boys' varsity, girls' varsity), cheerleading (JV, varsity), track (boys' varsity, girls' varsity), baseball (varsity), and softball (varsity).
The athletic department is headed by Athletic Director Karen Lyke.